Etec vs Yamaha

Endeavour · 26 January 2007, 21:04

I just come across this. Don't know if its already been posted

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_-7I00cZUE0

Biggles · 26 January 2007, 21:07

Nice one, Shame about the Yam. Still think I prefer the Yam though, that test would need to be carried out many times for me to think that the ETec was that much better.

codprawn · 27 January 2007, 18:00

Engine trim could make ALL the difference in a test like that. also they said the engines were propped to makers spec - that could mean one was running a 24" versus a 16" on the other - still in spec!!!

IBWET · 27 January 2007, 18:21

Quote:

Originally Posted by codprawn

Engine trim could make ALL the difference in a test like that. also they said the engines were propped to makers spec - that could mean one was running a 24" versus a 16" on the other - still in spec!!!

That's what I thought, the variables are potentially huge, I don't believe that the difference seen there, would be produced, if two 150's with same final drive, prop, boat weight and trim where hooked together. one would have the edge but I don't think to that extent.....

commercial envolvement me thinks.

Roy Smith · 27 January 2007, 18:36

i,am surprised that yamaha havant had there own back

vince · 27 January 2007, 19:08

Its definately a set-up! No wash from the Yam! Independant bloke watching everthing done right? My ass

pathalla · 30 January 2007, 03:05

total horseshit, no propwash off the Yamaha, it's insulting that they think people are that stupid, but I guess some are. Take a look at your stern wash when you nail it with an outboard, any outboard and then look again at this video..

howe · 30 January 2007, 20:11

I think you'd always get that result from standstill given similar props. Two stoke has more power strokes and that's usually reflected in the acceleration figures. Its not the same at the top end. This doesn't tell me anything new.

tiverton_tom · 08 February 2007, 18:48

Greetings all outboard enthusiasts.

Well it is time to "refresh" my outboards on my 24' aluminum hulled whale-watching RIB.

Originally I planned to put twin Yamaha 115 4-strokes on it, 3 years ago, but ended up going with the Honda 130s ( a private, "demo" deal ). My Honda dealer is losing Honda line, and is suggesting the Evinrude E-TECs. I could go up to twin 150s ($$) or down to 115s ....... or the Yamaha 115s that I think would do alright too. ...... but how much speed am I going to lose and/or increase gas consumption from my 130s?

The twin 130s (approx 1000 hours) are fully dealer maintained and have alot of life in them, if someone is looking for a great set up (or possibly separately).

tom

Tom Goodwin
Ocean Explorations Zodiac Whale Cruises
Tiverton, Long Island, Nova Scotia
902.839.2417, winter/home:834-2830
toll free reservations 1.877.654.2341
http://www.oceanexplorations.ca

bayblast · 13 February 2007, 20:56

I have a lot of Etec's and can belive it

Aidan · 13 February 2007, 23:32

Quote:

Originally Posted by tiverton_tom

Greetings all outboard enthusiasts.

Well it is time to "refresh" my outboards on my 24' aluminum hulled whale-watching RIB.

Originally I planned to put twin Yamaha 115 4-strokes on it, 3 years ago, but ended up going with the Honda 130s ( a private, "demo" deal ). My Honda dealer is losing Honda line, and is suggesting the Evinrude E-TECs. I could go up to twin 150s ($$) or down to 115s ....... or the Yamaha 115s that I think would do alright too. ...... but how much speed am I going to lose and/or increase gas consumption from my 130s?

The twin 130s (approx 1000 hours) are fully dealer maintained and have alot of life in them, if someone is looking for a great set up (or possibly separately).

tom

Tom Goodwin
Ocean Explorations Zodiac Whale Cruises
Tiverton, Long Island, Nova Scotia
902.839.2417, winter/home:834-2830
toll free reservations 1.877.654.2341
http://www.oceanexplorations.ca

Hi Tom, I am interested as to why your friend is loosing Honda agency?

Is it down to the units he is selling, or what? This is not a loaded question, I am just trying to suss where Honda is going. Its not like The Japs to lessen the amount of units they can unload!!!

Alex-341 · 18 February 2007, 00:22

Theres a whole load of videos like this on the Evinrude website, all of which seem ridiculous. In this and the others the Evinrudes look to have been proped for the job, and the Yams have had the wrong prop on. Was I the only one that noticed the idiot driving the yamaha didn't put the throttle on until he was going backwards?

tiverton_tom · 21 February 2007, 14:07

Aiden,
They told me Honda is going to more exclusive "stores" for all their honda products.

I guess this dealer sells too many other brands. He is dictated to sell some by the master corporation that makes & sells boats and outboards. I think he had to chose which outboards etc. he stuck with.

tom