I've owned 7 coms they have all failed! I've owned I've owne 4 SH and they haven't. I always recomend SH's to my emplyers and so far it's been a good recomendation. I think the 1500 is a cracking unit and well within your budget.
There a member of this forum who used to be the sales manager for Icom and Then SH, why don't you PM himand ask his Opinion. His name is Jon Brooksbut I wouldn't mention my name