Mike,
Our 2006 Tohatsu 9.8 2-stroke weighs just 2kg more than your 4hp Mariner with a very similar physical bulk. It will troll for hours at low speed with no oiling, using a quality oil we never notice smoke (unless you start it in the shed in a water tub), it uses very little fuel and has less parts to go wrong than a 4-stroke, is quiet and very easy to start.
So for your river use to all intents there are no downsides compared to yours... but get out onto the open sea or lochs and it will carry you about at up to 16-19 mph and allow a greater ability to pick your way through the waves if it gets rough.
The fun per lb ratio is very high!
David