After many years spending a small fortune and playing with shiny props, I have come to the conclusion that 99% of the time the factory fitted prop works best for general use in a standard powered leisure application. The manufactures do a lot of testing of props, they know what they are doing.
On an underpowered boat like yours (sorry to be blunt) I would leave it alone, I'm pretty sure that a 4 blade prop, regardless of size, will make thingsworse.
BTW,the current use for 1 of my props that I was convinced would transform my boat is a little less glamorous