New expensive RIB or old cheap speedboat?

[BogMonster]

I think I know the answer I am going to get, given that this is "RIBnet" but here goes anyway apologies in advance if any of these are dumb questions as I know next to nothing about boats, some guys on the LR4x4.com forum pointed me in this direction so you can blame them!

I don't have any sort of boat at the moment but am looking to get something soon. I've had a search around and read a number of the threads on buying but it doesn't really answer the question that is occupying my mind at the moment.

I live in the Falkland Islands and second-hand boats of any sort here are relatively rare so there's not a lot of choice, and freighting something down from the UK is quite expensive. My possible choices at the moment are a fairly old 5.8m speedboat - I don't know exactly how old and nor does the owner but it's got a 1990 Poole harbour dues sticker on it so presumably at least that old - or possibly a 3-4 year old RIB, though I haven't caught up with the owner yet.

Knowing nothing about boats I don't know what "type" the speedboat is, it was registered as the Blue Chip in Poole (its still on the stern albeit a bit faded) and it also has "Wildcat" on it which may be the type? It's got a 140hp Evinrude 2 stroke outboard as the main engine, plus a small aux outboard.

The RIB that may be available is a Humber Destroyer 5.8m with a 115hp outboard, Mariner 2 stroke I think (haven't seen it yet though) so likely to be in good condition so I am told, with a price that reflects that.

The speedboat is somewhat cheaper than the RIB, but obviously a lot older and that is my concern.

So if I were to buy something of this age, am I likely to be inheriting a heap of trouble in a couple of years time with structural problems with the fibreglass? I know this is RIBnet but I figured that the same sort of rules apply to a RIB hull as a speedboat hull in terms of useful life and structural soundness.

It seems to go well enough and the engine runs well (its not the original engine because the original apparently lost an argument with a reef a few years ago), zips along at about 40 which from what I have read is the sort of performance I might expect to get from the RIB so there's not much in it from that point of view. To my totally inexperienced eye it seems mostly OK, there's some minor damage on the keel but nothing that looks serious, and it "feels" solid enough thumping over waves - i.e. it doesn't feel structurally unsound or anything nasty. It's certainly not had any damage "covered up" recently - the hull is in quite serious need of a bit of paint but hasn't had anything done to it for some time.

My preference would be for a RIB if all things (especially price) were equal - the whole wind in the hair experience, been on one a few times and totally hooked, whereas the speedboat has a full (albeit home made) cabin, but with the climate here being unpredictable that's not a bad thing to have. Basically I'm looking for something to mess around with on fine days, serious seagoing ability is not really required (unless I get really hooked) though if it was, I think the speedboat would be more suitable.

So, would I be better to spend the extra (which I don't really have at the moment) and get the newer RIB, or is the speedboat likely to be a safe bet on the basis that if nothing obviously looks wrong, then probably nothing is wrong?

Any help, suggestions or advice on what to poke/prod at would be much appreciated! It isn't possible to get any sort of survey done because I don't think anybody round here does that sort of thing.

Many thanks

Stephen

[roofer]

If the boat is a winner wildcat its was made in the70's or early 80's, Parts are hard to come by for the evinrude engine, I'd give it a miss if I were you.imho!

[Ian Sharlot]

The humber sounds good. 115 2 stroke will drink some fuel unless it is a 115 optimax which is a good lump

[Nos4r2]

I wouldn't go anywhere near a hull that had a home-built cabin on it-you can bet there's water in the wooden stringers and floor.

[codprawn]

Wow what a place to live - must visit the islands one day.

Mind you is it really worth going 12,000 miles when I only live 25 miles from the Brecon beacons - they look pretty similar!!!

As regards your choices I would gop for the Humber if money is no object - if the speedboat is seriously cheap then it's worth looking at. The engine is the most important thing - spares supply and servicing.

I have seen some pretty ropey looking old speedboats that get a new lease of life with a decent outboard on them.

[The Garfish]

Originally Posted by BogMonster

I live in the Falkland Islands

Originally Posted by BogMonster

it was registered as the Blue Chip in Poole

i sowld dat bote in 1993 too sum nobbur hoo sed hee wontid too crooze alorng de sowf cowst

i didd tel im de GSP wennt a likkul bitt wonnky sumtymes

gArf

[Paul F]

Hi
Given your location and the unpredicted sea states you have down there(been there ribbing and got T shirt).
Would plumb for the RIB.
Paul

[BogMonster]

Thanks for the replies so far

roofer - if I posted a photo of it (haven't got one at the moment) would you be able to identify it as being a 'Winner Wildcat' if that is in fact what it is? It makes it a lot older than I had been led to believe - but I don't know if anybody here really knows (I've asked around). Does that mean it's probably just about on its last legs at that sort of age? Since it has been here I know for a fact that it has been stored out of the water most of the time by both the current owner (who hardly ever uses it) and the guy who got it down, it used to sit up in his yard on a trailer much of the time.

Nos4r2 - I should have given a bit more detail - basically the previous owner but one "boxed in" behind the two seats to make the cabin weatherproof, as it would originally have been supplied it just had a front screen and nothing on top, any water coming in over the sides drains into a proper bilge at the stern which was part of the original design, so would this still be a problem?

Garfish - not sure if you were being serious or not when you said you had sold it?! if you were, do you know what age it would be?

What would the weak points on the Evinrude engine be and why are the parts not available - is it just a type that is long out of production?

I'd like the RIB but it's a lot more money for something that at the moment is probably just going to be to play with on weekends, haven't spoken to the owner yet but likely to be somewhere around eight or nine grand against five for the Chip.

Thanks

Stephen

[TJ101]

Hi "Bogmonster", nice to see you found the site !! Welcome Stephen!!

If "only " 4k between the 2, i would have a look at the Humber before you comit, so you can see what you get for the extra cash !!

The rib, subject to age,condition etc,, sounds about right, but "if" a winner wildcat, the price sema to be all the money for it !!

Regards Tim

[BogMonster]

Hi Tim

Thanks I thought about registering as "BogMonster" on here but thought it would seem a bit out of place

I am told by a mutual friend that the RIB is about 4 yrs old, something like 200 hours on the engine, purchased new by the guy who now has it, at the same time as my friend got one (which he has now sold). What's the useful life of a 2 stroke outboard? 2 stroke motocross bike engines seem to need rebuilding about every other week, don't want that!!

The Wildcat (if that is what it is) - what would that go for elsewhere, assuming fair condition (and it seems OK to my untrained eye, not falling to bits or anything). The asking price is £5k but he paid £6.5k for it a year or so back, so he says. As I said this includes aux engine, trailer, fishfinder, etc etc.

The other thing is I've been Googling for a while and I can find out absolutely nothing about Winner Wildcats.... anybody point me in the right direction of some info or are they all scrapped now?!

[TJ101]

Steve, as i remember a winner wildcat was something like this

http://www.boatsandoutboards.co.uk/view/F81871/

back over here, would guess the one you are looking at would be 3.4 -4 k ish,asking, but you have to factor in, cost to ship to your ?? £1000/1200 maybe ??

As mentioned, most of the valve/possable problems are in the engine, have a word with the local dealer,s mechinics, to see if they are ok to look after/get bits if needed !!

Tim

[codprawn]

http://leisure.uk.freeads.net/THIS_I...T.I-107912.htm

Possibly another one like your boat???

[dctucker]

In my experience, old fiberglass hulls don't really die, they just get banged up, scratched and faded. Unless they have a balsa or plywood core, the hulls really don't deteriorate. As someone else has mentioned, if there's structural wood in the boat, that's the part that can go bad if it's wet. Other than that, it's all about the condition of the engine.

Get the rib!

[BogMonster]

Tim - that was about the only thing my search turned up was that one.

The hull looks very similar but then I guess the wet bit on most speedboats will be more or less the same shape, form following function - the dry bit looks quite a bit different though, and the stern around the motor mount is different to the one codprawn found. It does have a very similar looking triple-paned front screen but the interior is considerably less "agricultural".

There isn't really anybody here specialising in boat maintenance, not that sort anyway (if you want a jigger or trawler fixed that's OK though!) as there are relatively few here and I think most owners probably do (or don't) their own maintenance.

So I don't really know what to do - I'll have a look at the RIB first anyway, not in a big hurry despite the weather having been producing a lot of "I wish I had a boat today" days lately! Seems to me like rushing into this could be ill-advised, better to think about it and look at all the other options.

Yeah - freight for anything shipped ex UK is likely to be about £1000 minimum - a 5m boat is gonna be about 10cbm shipping volume give or take, anything bigger is going to be more. That's my biggest problem really - lack of options available locally - wish I had some of the selection from over there to choose from!!!

[stu1288]

not being funny but i wouldnt even think of spending that much money on sumthing that old as for the engine though you can get all the parts you will ever need from american marine imports they are fairly cheap too and get all the parts to you within a couple of days.
if its sumthing that old then i'd be looking to pay £2500
i mean if your intrested in a 17ft fletcher with 90hp mariner ,snipe trailer then im looking for about 4000 4 it

put ur purse in your back pocket and sit on it (dont get up till ur goin to see that rib)

[xpertski]

i would say without a doubt go for the rib, an old speedboat like that could turn out to be allot of problems, i dont know if its possible, but if you went out in both boats youd notice a massive difference, as has been mentioned, i wouldnt pay 5k for an old speedboat like that, and if cost means the rib simply isnt possible, then make sure yu get a bargain on the other boat, i would also say in the region of 2.5k-3k! the humbers are ery good boats, and i would assume the engine may be an opti.......do you know? because it would make a big difference on the quality of set up!

at the end of the day you may find that paying £1000 to ship a rib from here over thereis worth it to ensure you get the boat you want, there are plenty of sub 5k ribs over here that i would rather have than the speedboat!!!

i can vouch for humber

[jwalker]

I vaguely recollect someone from ribnet giving training in the Faulklands. Could it have been Wavelength? It might be worth having a chat.

[BogMonster]

I think it was - as part of my searching I searched for "Falklands" and one or two came up and that name rings a bell.

Another question which occurred to me while watching somebody on the weekend in a Rigid Raider (which is quite heavy) with not much more than the prop in the water going into a strong headwind - what is the "critical airspeed" of a RIB in terms of when you start to get a serious danger of it flipping up if it comes out of the water over a wave? Wind speed here is often 25 knots or so, and any kind of a serious speed into that kind of headwind is start to get up to the speed where most small aeroplanes fly ... what about small boats?! just a thought.... sorry its probably a stupid newbie question but the thought did cross my mind!

I'll try and find out more about the rib and maybe have a go in it to see how it compares to the boat.

Thanks

[Bittentobuggery]

Stephen,

If I was in your situation, I would take the time to come over here and test 12 or 15 boats and talk to some of the dealers about good and bad points on different models. I would not be making a choice between the two options that are available to you locally.

Hopefully, you would find something that you reallly like and will be thoroughly suitable. When you have it shipped back, make sure that you include the spares/consumables that you will need for your choice.

Even if you came over and bought nothing (because of the expense ?) it would still be a good investment and you may find that you have saved yourself from buying a dog !!

My humble opinion only...


'Shooz

[Scary Des]

Given this news you might want to buy a tank instead Des