Hi Sealion, I purchased a 2008 Ribeye 650s with an F150 engine this February and love the boat so good choice of boat
My boat is heavily anti-fouled which is rough as its patchy but with a 19" pitch prop I get 5700 - 5800 RPM and a top speed (according to yam gauges) of 42 - 44 knots so there is definitely an issue with that setup you have just sea trialed.
The 19" pitch prop is the setup recommended by Ribeye / Yamaha.
I did quite a bit of research on these boats so if you need any advice or other questions just pm me
Good Luck